Wine, from vine to glass

Tasting7 min read

Aerating or decanting wine: when, why and how

Aerating a young wine or separating an old vintage from its sediment: when to use a carafe, when to decant, and how long before serving.

Illustration: garnet colour, seen from above in a glass

The two gestures are often confused, yet they have opposite aims. Aerating (in French, carafer) means exposing a young wine to air so it opens up. Decanting (décanter) means separating an old wine from its sediment while exposing it to as little air as possible. Chosen well, they transform a bottle; chosen badly, they can spoil it. Find the other basics in our wine tasting guide.

Aerating a young wine

A young, tannic wine can seem closed when opened: few aromas and slightly hard tannins. Contact with air softens it and releases its aromas. Pour the whole bottle in one go into a wide-based carafe, which offers a large surface in contact with air.

Wines that benefit:

  • young, tannic reds: Bordeaux, Madiran, Cahors, Rhône Syrah, young Cabernets;
  • some age-worthy whites served young: white Burgundy, dry Loire Chenin, Savennières;
  • wines with a slight reductive smell on opening, which disappears with air.

How long? One hour is usually enough, two for very young and powerful wines. Taste when you pour, then every thirty minutes.

Decanting an old wine

Over the years, reds form a sediment: pigments and tannins that bind together and fall to the bottom of the bottle. They are harmless but bitter, and they cloud the wine. Decanting lets you serve a clear wine.

The method:

  1. Stand the bottle upright 24 to 48 hours before the meal, so the sediment settles.
  2. Open it gently, without shaking.
  3. Pour slowly into a narrow decanter, in front of a light: a lamp or a candle under the neck.
  4. Stop as soon as the sediment reaches the neck. A little wine is left in the bottle; that’s normal.

When? Just before serving. An old vintage is fragile: its aromas can fade in under an hour in contact with air.

Wines best left in the bottle

  • Sparkling wines, which would lose their bubbles.
  • Light, fruity reds such as Beaujolais: aeration adds almost nothing.
  • Very old, fragile wines, to serve straight from a well-rested bottle.

And temperature?

A spell in the carafe warms the wine slightly. Serve it at the right temperature, as shown in our table of serving temperatures. To describe what you notice before and after aeration, use the three steps of wine tasting. And if there is wine left over, here is how long an opened bottle lasts.

What happens in the carafe

In contact with air, some volatile compounds evaporate, including those that give a musty smell on opening. Fruit and spice aromas become more noticeable, and tannins feel softer. Scientists still debate how large these effects are, but sommeliers’ experience is consistent: a young, powerful wine is often more enjoyable after an hour of air.

How long to aerate: the table

Type of wine Aerate? Suggested time
Young, tannic red (Bordeaux, Madiran, Cahors) Yes 1–2 hours
Young Rhône Syrah or Grenache Yes 1 hour
Young Burgundy Pinot Noir Sometimes 30 minutes at most
Beaujolais, light red Rarely Not needed
Age-worthy white served young Sometimes 30 minutes
Red over 15 years old Decant only Just before serving
Champagne, crémant No —

Double decanting

To serve an aerated wine while showing the bottle at the table, double-decant. Pour the wine into a carafe, rinse the bottle with clean water to remove the sediment, then pour the wine back into the bottle. The wine is aerated, sediment-free, and your guests can see the label. The technique also helps when you have only one carafe for several bottles: aerate each wine in turn, then return it to its bottle until serving. Just make sure the rinsed bottle is well drained.

Reduced wines and natural wines

Some wines, especially those aged away from air or with little sulphur, give off an unpleasant smell of egg or struck match on opening, known as reduction. It isn’t necessarily a lasting fault: vigorous aeration in a carafe often makes it disappear within minutes. If the smell persists after half an hour, the fault runs deeper.

The sommelier’s moves

  • Cut the capsule below the lip, so the wine doesn’t touch the metal as it pours.
  • Wipe the neck after removing the cork.
  • Smell the cork: a musty, damp-cardboard smell signals a corked wine, which no aeration will save.
  • Pour in a steady stream, bottle tilted, without jolts.
  • Taste before serving, to check the wine is ready.

Aerator or carafe?

Aerators fit on the neck or are held over the glass: the wine flows through them and mixes with air as it is poured. They are handy for a glass served quickly, but their effect is shorter and rougher than time in a carafe. For a young, powerful wine, the carafe remains more effective. For a fragile old wine, avoid the aerator, which would expose it to too much air.

At a restaurant

If you order a young, tannic wine, don’t hesitate to ask the sommelier to aerate it. Good restaurants do it without extra charge, and the sommelier will usually taste a drop to check the wine is sound. If you bring your own bottle, where corkage is allowed, the same service is generally offered. For an old vintage, they will often offer to decant it in front of you. You can also order the bottle at the start of the meal, to give it time to open up before the main course.

Choosing a carafe

To aerate, choose a wide-based carafe that spreads the wine over a large surface. To decant an old wine, prefer a narrower decanter that limits contact with air. Clear, undecorated glass lets you see how clear the wine is. To clean it, rinse with hot water and use a few cleaning beads, without washing-up liquid whose smell would linger. Let it dry upside down and avoid the dishwasher, which dulls fine glass.

Which glasses to use

Once aerated, serve the wine in a stemmed, tulip-shaped glass wide enough to swirl. Fill it only a third full: the wine keeps breathing in the glass and its aromas gather at the rim.

In short

  • Young, tannic wine: aerate one to two hours ahead, in a wide carafe.
  • Old wine with sediment: stand the bottle up the day before and decant just before serving.
  • Reduced wine: aerate vigorously and taste after a few minutes.
  • Sparkling and light reds: leave them in the bottle.
  • When in doubt: taste on opening, then every thirty minutes. Your palate remains the best judge.

French terms at the table

  • Carafer: to aerate a young wine in a carafe.
  • Décanter: to separate an old wine from its sediment.
  • Dépôt: sediment.
  • Réduit: reduced, a closed smell of egg or struck match.
  • Bouchonné: corked.

Frequently asked questions

Can you aerate white wine? Yes, some age-worthy whites served young benefit from half an hour of air: white Burgundy, dry Chenin, great Rhône whites. Keep the carafe cool afterwards.

Can aerating too long spoil the wine? Yes, especially for older wines, which lose their aromas. For a young wine the risk is low over a few hours, but beyond half a day it runs out of steam.

No carafe: what can you do? Pour the glasses in advance and swirl the wine in the glass. You can also pour the bottle into a clean jug, then back into the rinsed bottle.

Is sediment a fault? No. It is a natural sign of ageing, common in lightly filtered wines. Just decant.